TRANSCENDENTAL FIELD: KANT AND HUSSERL
QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION:
THE TRANSCENDENTAL
FIELD
DISTINCTIONS BETWEEN
KANT AND HUSSERL
General aspects to consider[1]
1.
What
is quid factis et quid juris in each
one.
2.
The
presumptive transcendental field of Kant and the husserlian noetic turn in view
of the principle of every principle.
3.
Formal
field in Kant and the eidetic field in Husserl.
4.
Transcendental
esthetic in Kant and the phenomenological realm of appearing by its evidence.
5.
A
priori concepts in Kant and the a priori correlation in Husserl.
6.
The
access to the transcendental field in Kant is by analysis and deduction of
concepts (pure or not) and in Husserl is by phenomenological reflection whose
first step is epoché. After epoché Husserl indicates three possible paths:
the logical, the psychological and the Cartesian one.
7.
The
regulative function of concepts for the whole of knowledge in Kant and the
inter-monadic and historical discovering of ideas in Husserl.
8.
The
limited structure for knowledge of Kant following Euclidean and Newtonian
paradigms of empirical objectivity (in its presumptive principles) and the
constrictive pure Logic of transversal deductive function of the theory of
multiplicity theory possible in Husserl (in 1901) and its historical complexity,
and on the other hand the constrictive function of phenomenology for the
authenticity of knowledge possible -including the contemporary scientific
achievements- and sense world possible.
9.
Kant
did not inquire immanent objects neither the living experience itself. Perhaps,
there is in Kant something like that in the subjective deduction of the
categories in the first edition of KrV,
but he did not take the problem of the subjectivity of the living experience.
And as we know, this is the proper realm of phenomenology.
[1] Some aspects considered here are
taken from the classes of Roberto Walton in a study group that we conformed
with some friends in UBA, Buenos Aires, 2006-2008. Organizing my studies here,
I cannot resist the enormous greeting feeling for his philosophical generosity.
Comments
Post a Comment